The Denver Gazette

Builder sues Denver over affordable housing fees

BY MARK SAMUELSON The Denver Gazette

A homebuilder that specializes in entry-level prices in popular neighborhoods, such as Berkeley and Sunnyside, took on the city of Denver on Monday in federal court, challenging whether “mandated affordable” home requirements and fees charged to builders stand up to constitutional scrutiny.

“It disgusts me that we’re passing (city charges) on to buyers while we give handouts to others,” builder Nathan Adams, CEO of Denver-based redT Homes LLC, told The Denver Gazette following oral arguments presented yesterday in the 10th Circuit on his company’s behalf by the Pacific Legal Foundation.

The case challenges the constitutionality of city regulations requiring builders to choose between offering some of their homes for projects in Denver at well-below-market prices to help create more affordable housing or paying a “linkage fee” on each home that is nominally used by the city to support affordable housing. Denver’s Mandatory Affordable Housing Ordinance went into effect in 2022.

Counterproductive?

The Denver Gazette reached out to the Denver City Attorney’s office for a comment on the case and did not receive a response at press time. In a June filing, Adam C. Hernandez of the City Attorney’s office said Denver’s law does not violate redT’s Fifth Amendment rights “that result in an uncompensated taking.”

The U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado dismissed the case at the request of the city, ruling that, “under the circumstances of this case, redT could only challenge the MAHO as a per se physical taking, and that redT had failed to state a valid claim under this theory.”

“redT has not alleged a plausible unconstitutional exactions claim because it has failed to allege that the MAHO constitutes a per se physical taking,” Denver said in a legal brief in June. “In order to analyze whether an exaction imposes an unconstitutional condition on a land use permit, the condition must be a compensable taking outside of the permitting context, or it must require the payment of money to the government.”

Pacific Legal Foundation lead attorney David Deerson told The Denver Gazette that the system proves doubly counterproductive for a builder like redT that already specializes in some of the lowest-priced new units brought to market.

“redT is a great developer of sustainable homes,” Deerson said. “When you’re dealing with a housing crisis, in which Denver needs supply, it’s totally backward to put the burden of solving the problem on those who provide it.”

A statement by the foundation that accompanied its initial court arguments called redT a key contributor in helping allay Denver’s housing shortage.

“But rather than embrace the efforts of builders like redT, Denver enacted an inclusionary zoning program that does the exact opposite,” the group said. “The result: Developers have to increase the price of homes to cover the increased costs, making it harder for Denver families to buy homes.”

Supreme Court decisions in 1987 and 1994, the group’s attorney argued, had ruled that governments could not burden homebuilders with costs for problems they do not create.

“Those cases established that permit conditions for new construction must be proportional and directly related to its impact,” the statement said. “Anything above and beyond is an unconstitutional property taking.”

The group’s statement added that redT had been priced out of some projects by the requirements and that an upcoming work for four single-family homes would be subject to $25,000 in fees, while another, for two duplexes, would be subject to $45,000.

When the regulations are applied to a builder of redT’s scale, doing smaller projects, having to choose between building mandated affordable units and paying a fee is actually just a fee, Deerson said.

“From a practical perspective, nobody building under 10 units will choose to do mandated affordable housing,” he added. “We argued that it’s like a cudgel used to force people into paying the fees. For anybody building a fourplex, it makes more sense to pay the fees.”

Adams said that 90% or more of what his company has built over time has been affordably priced housing. When the company began building homes in 2011, that entry-level price the company delivered was in the high $300,000s to low $400,000s, but now the range would be from the $400,000s to $700,000s. He said he currently has small projects where a fee would be paid, along with two larger ones that are being compensated by offering below-market units.

On a recent project in Denver’s Rosedale neighborhood, which seeks to deliver four townhome units, the company paid linkage fees of $48,000 — $12,000 per door, he said, adding that prices for the homes were initially projected to be in the $900,000s but are now around $809,000.

In Denver’s Berkeley neighborhood, north of W. 38th Avenue at Perry Street, Adams is nearing completion on 40 units, with most to be priced from $550,000 to $750,000, along with two mandated affordable units that he expects to be priced in the low $300,000s.

The downside for buyers who can qualify for the two below-market units is that they will be limited to a lower rate on any future appreciation.

“It is a disingenuous handout,” Adams said.

In the current market, he added, where typical homes are depreciating, those owners may actually come out ahead, but when typical appreciation returns, they will be held back from benefiting. Denver argues that “the MAHO is only a restriction on the use of the property; it does not take other interests in the property.”

“The MAHO limits the sales price of income restricted units, but that limitation does not in and of itself extinguish any fundamental right to sell property at a price of one’s choosing,” the city’s brief said. “Limitations on sales price are not categorically unconstitutional, either at the federal or state law level. Colorado has adopted price controls under its general police power authority.”

Deerson said that the legality of the city’s policies would have come under court scrutiny earlier, but that they had effectively been accepted as city ordinances. A newer U.S. Supreme Court case overturning a decision by the California Supreme Court in 2023 served as a warning that Denver’s policies would be subject to the earlier U.S. Supreme Court cases, he said.

He added the outcome of the case would prove important not just in Denver but throughout the territory of the 10th Circuit, which covers much of the Rocky Mountain West.

“The arguments went very well and were very encouraging,” Deerson said. “All three judges took our invitation to grapple with the legal issues and with ways the law has changed since the last time the 10th Circuit looked at these programs.”

FRONT PAGE

en-us

2026-11-18T07:00:00.0000000Z

2026-11-18T07:00:00.0000000Z

https://daily.denvergazette.com/article/281509348238928

Colorado Springs Gazette